Justice 4 ALL Madeleine McCann Family
You need to be a member of this forum in order to view its entire contents.
We welcome applications to join the forum from genuine caring compassionate people that wish to support Mr Mrs McCann in their never ending resolve to finding their daughter Madeleine and bringing her back home where she truly belongs.

All applicants are checked out so people with no sense, no moral compass, no rationality and only half a brain cell and even less grip on reality and who are devoid of all logic - need NOT apply!
This also applies to ex-members, who no longer want to be members, yet spend their lives viewing this forum and telling people they no longer want to be members.
This is said without prejudice with no one in particular in mind.

158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Page 1 of 3 1, 2, 3  Next

View previous topic View next topic Go down

158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Rosie on Tue Aug 05, 2008 4:30 am

I have come up with 86 questions I would like to ask Goncalo Amaral, if you have anymore please feel free to post them and I will add them to the running total.

Running Total 86 89 93 101 104 106 141 148 153 158 and still rising! (keep them coming, they are flooding in by email too) It appears that many people would like Goncalo Amaral to answer questions!

Questions to Amaral...

  1. You had a call from an English couple in deep distress, their daughter had vanished, the whole of PDL (except for Robert Murat) was out searching for her.

  2. Why did *you* assume the child had wandered off?

  3. Did you yourself and your men think to search the wardrobe and behind the sofa?

  4. Did you not consider sweeping the wardrobe and behind the sofa for vital evidence, in fact did you not consider closing down the apartment and getting it properly examined by properly trained forensics teams *IMMEDIATELY*?

  5. Why did you leave this couple to do their own searching, while you went home to bed?

  6. In view that it was *YOUR* obligation and *YOUR* job to see that a crime scene is properly secured, why did *YOU* allow so many people to contaminate it?

  7. Why did you expect distraught parents to do *your* job and secure a crime scene?

  8. Why did you not go to the scene and take control of the situation and do your job properly?

  9. Why did you not stay and order the flat to be cleared of all people that should not be there and then order that it be cordoned off *IMMEDIATELY*?

  10. Why did you go home *knowing that the crime scene was being contaminated* and go to sleep and then ask the parents why they allowed people into the apartment?

  11. Is it true that you never attended the scene yourself on the night Madeleine was abducted, but coordinated the investigation by phone? Where *exactly* did you coordinate this investigation from?

  12. If the above is true, then did you tell the investigating officers to secure the crime scene?

  13. If it is true that you never attended the scene that night of May 3rd, how were you so sure that Madeleine was not abducted? How do you know that Kate sat on Madeleine's bed traumatised unable to move?

  14. How was it possible to coordinate the search for a missing toddler over the telephone?

  15. To an ordinary person, you are told a child has gone missing, the first thing you do is to search the place. *BEHIND* the sofa in the *WARDROBE* behind the *CURTAINS*, why do you think this is odd? Why did *YOU* not stop them?

  16. Why did you not organise a search for the child IMMEDIATELY?

  17. Why did you not get a forensics team in IMMEDIATELY?

  18. Why did you not set an operations centre up in Mark Warner and order the lock down of the complex?

  19. Why did you not ask MW manager for a list of all staff and all people holidaying immediately?

  20. Why did you not order the organisation of the immediate interviewing of all MW staff and residents?

  21. Have you taken DNA samples from all residents, all holiday makers and all staff present at MW on and shortly before May 3rd?

  22. Why did you not order the Spanish borders with Portugal to be informed you had a missing child believed abducted and issue them with photographs and details?

  23. Same with the Marina just short distance away, why did you not order the lock down of this Marina?

  24. Why did you not inform authorities at the airport?

  25. Why did it take you 12 hours after Madeleine went missing to alert all border controls?

  26. Why did you allow Mark Warner cleaning staff to come in and clean apartment 5a and then ask Kate McCann why the flat had been cleaned?

  27. Why did you allow MW staff to enter this flat *a crime scene* and remove *vital evidence* such as the child's bedding?

  28. If you did not attend the crime scene and view the bed for yourself, how could you say that the bed did not look like it had been slept in? In any even the bed did look like it had been slept in by a small child and it looked like someone had turned the bedclothes back to lift her out. Why did you say that the bed was harldy touched then accuse Kate of sitting on it?

  29. Did you at anytime think that the abductor could have been putting up a pretence and searching the flat?

  30. Why did you not order an immediate circulation of this child's picture, so people knew who they were looking for?

  31. During the *POLICE* searches, and with the police present, in what locations was Maddie searched for, how and in what manner?

  32. Where were you during these searches and what were you doing?

  33. Why did you not organise an immediate 15K ring search centering around the area that Madeleine disappeared from?

  34. Why did you not order an immediate fingertip search at first light outside from where Madeleine went missing, instructing people what to look for, cigarette butts, matches, etc and tell them how to gather and secure this evidence?

  35. How many flats have been searched in the MW complex and when were they searched?

  36. When were the MW buildings searched? ie cellars, offices, backs of restaurants, empty apartments etc?

  37. How many private properties near to the MW complex have been searched?

  38. Did you organise an immediate search of all barns, gardens and cellars in the immediate vicinity?

  39. How many 3 and 4 hour long lunch breaks did you take during the 4 months you were meant to be looking for Madeleine McCann?

  40. Do you always drink alcohol while on duty?

  41. Is it a part of your investigative techniques to talk about and reveal highly sensitive information during an ongoing high profile police investigation?

  42. Is it true that finger prints were not lifted from this apartment until five days after Madeleine went missing?

  43. Is it true that the first finger prints lifted from the apartment were not taken properly and had to be re taken?

  44. Why didn't the forensics technician taking the finger prints from the shutter and the bedroom window dress appropriately in accordance with international guidelines for taking forensic evidence?

  45. Is it true that proper forensic examination of this flat did not take place until Day 100 after Madeleine went missing?

  46. When did you order a list of all paedophiles known to be in the area at this time?

  47. Have you been in touch with the German police and the Swiss police about two paedophiles known to be in Praia da Luz at the time of Madeleine McCann's disappearance?

  48. What time did the first call come in to which the GNR responded?

  49. What time did the GNR request the PJ to come to the apartment?

  50. How long after the call came in did it take you to respond to the GNR and what time did you arrive at the apartment?

  51. Did you immediately dispatch teams of your men and the GNR to do preliminary searches?

  52. Why were the bins in luz allowed to be emptied shortly after Madeleine went missing?

  53. Has the waste tip where the rubbish from Praia da Luz is taken been searched thoroughly for any signs of Madeleine, or her pyjamas or anything else missing?

  54. Did you yourself question all known witnesses that night of May 3rd?

  55. Is it true that the witness Mrs Pamela Fenn said she heard A child crying and did NOT say she heard Madeleine crying?

  56. Did you ask your men to ask for all witnesses to come forward and make a list of them before you left the apartment that night to go home to bed?

  57. How long did you sleep knowing that a small child was missing from her bed?

  58. Do you always assume that small children going missing from their beds in the evenings have gone wandering off on their own in the dark?

  59. Did you think of asking the parents to ask the twins if they saw something? (Even though they were very small and asleep and you probably would not get a coherent logical answer?)

  60. Mr McCann pointed out to you he thought it was odd that the twins remained asleep during all the commotion, did you not think of getting the twins tested and physically examined by a doctor immediately as he suggested?

  61. Did you not think to stay and help this couple who were alone in a foreign country unable to speak the language, alone panicking and petrified?

  62. Taking the above into consideration, why did you think it was odd that a relative of theirs back in England contacted Sky news, some hours after Madeleine disappeared?

  63. Are you familiar with time immediately after a child is kidnapped, which is referred to as the *Golden Hours*? If you are, why did you not attend the scene, preferring to coordinate over the phone? How long *exactly* did you spend on the phone coordinating this investigation?

  64. Do you as a serving detective, not know the European drill for a missing child believed abducted? Where circulating a photo to the media is considered of vital importance?

  65. Were you aware of the 'Child Rescue Alert System' which has been employed across Europe since 2007? which was actually in force at the time Madeleine McCann went missing?

  66. If you did know of this drill, why did you not put the 6 Bullet Point list into operation immediately?
    *Description of the child
    *Scanned photo of the child
    *Details of location and nature of the offence
    *Description of the offender(s)
    *CCTV/photo of the offender(s)


  67. Concerning you professional career, how many missing child/abduction cases have you investigated?

  68. What was the outcome of those cases?

  69. Is there any controversy over those cases?

  70. Why did you think of bringing in sniffer dogs from the UK one month AFTER Madeleine went missing?

  71. When the McCann's moved out of this apartment, who else had access to it?

  72. Was the flat cordoned off and kept locked and secured and was it guarded at all times by a police guard after the McCann's had moved out?

  73. In your opinion could anyone have had sufficient time, motive and opportunity to plant evidence in that apartment?

  74. Can this scent of death be produced in a laboratory for dog training purposes? Is this produced in any lab in Portugal? Have you checked to see if anyone had recently purchased such a product? Have you checked out all those that have access to such product?

  75. Why did you deliberately pursue this line of enquiry reagrding the sniffer dogs when you *KNEW* that it was an extremely tenuous link to forensic evidence? When you knew because you had been told by the FSS in Birmingham that the evudence was inclonclusive and could have belonged to a great many of the population?

  76. Did you ever think that there may have been evidence left by the abductor/s that could have made the dogs react in this way?

  77. Is it a possibility that such evidence could have been missed because you did not order the immediate securing of a crime scene?

  78. Is it a possibility that the evidence of cleaning you have asked Mrs McCann about, could have been the evidence of cleaning left by the MW cleaners that you allowed to enter and clean a crime scene in the first few days after Madeleine disappeared?

  79. Is it possible that the blood found in the apartment 5a was found to be that of an Eastern European Male?

  80. Is it possible that the blood indicated by the above was what the dogs reacted to?

  81. Is it possible that the apartment was then cleaned again by those allowed to rent the apartment weeks after Madeleine went missing?

  82. Have you traced, spoken to and checked out the professions and the occupants of those that rented the apartment after Madeleine went missing?

  83. Is it true that pieces of paper which could have contained vital information in this investigation were just strewn about the PJ offices?

  84. Did you have a proper scene of crime room out of which to operate?

  85. Is it possible that the scent the dogs reacted to could have been placed there by previous holidaying occupants of apartment 5a before the McCann's arrived?

  86. When the cars were lined up to be exposed to the sniffer dogs, why did you allow this procedure to take place in a public car park and not a scientifically controlled scene?

  87. When these cars were lined up to be exposed to the dogs, why did you allow the McCann's hire car to remain highly identifiable by allowing the find Madeleine bright yellow stickers all over it?

  88. Is it true that the sniffer dogs walked past all cars in the line up indicating a NEGATIVE

  89. Bearing that in mind, how do you account for saying these dogs have never given a false sign in 200 cases?

  90. When the dogs walked past this vehicle and *FAILED* to indicate a positive reaction, why did you insist that they be brought back and walked around the car until they did indicate a positive?

  91. Did you have any idea that the dogs may indicate a positive if they were repeatedly subjected to walking around this particular vehicle?

  92. Is it true that the leaked report to the press of a boot print found inside the flat and on the bumper of the McCann's hire care was that of policeman belonging to the GNR?

  93. Is it true that ALL DNA evidence that has been found both inside the flat and the hire car is mitochondrial DNA which could have belonged to Madeleine, Amelie or Kate herself?

  94. Is it true that you misinterpreted the DNA evidence from the FSS in Birmingham UK AND that from the Portuguese forensic science lab?

  95. Why did you ignore the email from John Lowe of the FSS in Birmingham, 2 days BEFORE you made the McCanns arguidos, warning that the DNA samples were inconclusive and yet you still proceeded to make The McCanns arguidos ?

  96. Is it normal in Portugal for someone you suspect in the case you are investigating to be allowed allowed to translate during key witness interviews?

  97. Do you really think it unusual that the mother of a missing child, who has brought the worlds media to help in their plight, then found her husband has been made an arguido the night before (after answering all his questions)and realising you "want" them to be guilty, rather than investigate the real perpetrator, doesn't answer all your ridiculous questions?

  98. Why did you make them arguidos and then complain Kate would not answer questions, exercising her right to remain silent under the arguid status t you yourself placed her under?

  99. If you wanted Kate to answer your questions, why didn't you make her a witness, explaining that under Portuguese law, *witnesses* are obliged by law to answer police questions?

  100. Is it true you made the McCann's arguidos "too hastily" just 8 days BEFORE the law was Due to change in Portugal?

  101. Is it true that if you had waited to make the McCann's arguidos, you would have had to produce hard and fast evidence to do so? Is it true that you made the McCann's arguidos then because you had *NO* evidence to back your suspicions?

  102. Is it true that you presided over a highly sensitive investigation where leaks from within this investigation were repeatedly used to blacken the characters of Kate and Gerry McCann?

  103. Who do you think as been leaking highly sensitive reports to the Portuguese press?

  104. Why do you think they would leak these confidential reports to the press?

  105. Is it true that you dismissed many sightings..one in particular in Morocco, on the grounds that you assume Madeleine is dead and her parents are to blame?

  106. Is it also true that a member of the hotel staff saw a man hiding in the bush near the McCanns apartment??And Were there any footprints in the ground under that bush? If there were what was done about them? Were they investigated or ignored as many other sightings and leads appeared to have been? And if this is true, why?


Last edited by Rosiepops on Sun Aug 17, 2008 2:50 am; edited 14 times in total
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Good questions.

Post by calcite51 on Tue Aug 05, 2008 4:35 am

Rosie, I expect you're not really expecting any answers are you? Maybe when Clawsie comes back from holidays, she can answer them for you - don't count on it.
avatar
calcite51
Star Poster
Star Poster

Number of posts : 830
Location : Canada
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by littleminx on Tue Aug 05, 2008 4:40 am

rosie... your 81 questions are FANTASTIC wouldnt it be great if you could get amaral to answer them! what do you think hes answer,s would be? You know what rosie, i would love to see the anti,s answer your questions too.
avatar
littleminx
Master
Master

Number of posts : 450
Age : 50
Location : west midlands
Registration date : 2008-06-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Rosie on Tue Aug 05, 2008 4:58 am

They are up to 86 questions now and I am sure I will think of more.

So if any of you have some to add just post them and I will add them on.

Perhaps when they are finished I will print them off and send them to Goncalo Amaral and see how he answers them!
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Re: 86 Questions I Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by christabel on Tue Aug 05, 2008 5:10 am

Rosie I would like to ask him why he never attended the scene himself on the night Madeleine was kidnapped, but coordinated by phone.
What a good example this waster is (NOT).
avatar
christabel
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 1637
Age : 68
Location : OK
Registration date : 2008-04-26

Back to top Go down

120 Questions That We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral.

Post by clairesy on Tue Aug 05, 2008 5:59 am

OMG!!!!

We shall have to call you detective rosiepops from now on Rosie!!Those questions summed it all up in my mind...reading each of them i was able to answer them in the way i would imagine he would do so...

maybe he would also like to answer these.Just a couple i have wondered of amongst others which i think you have already addressed

Why were the bins in luz allowed to be emptied shortly after madeleine went missing?

Has the waste tip been searched thoroughly for any signs of madeleine?

Why was Robert Murat allowed to translate..even though you already suspected him?

Is it true you only allowed him to continue translating as you didn't want to arouse suspicion in him?

Why were you not there immediately after madeleine was reported missing...and where were you instead?

Who do you think as been leaking reports to the Portuguese press??

Why do you think they would leak these confidential reports??

Is it true that you dismissed many sightings..one in particular in morocco on the grounds that you assume she is dead?

Is it also true that a member of the hotel staff saw a man hiding in the bush near the mccanns apartment??AndWere there any footprints in the ground under that bush?

Could it be the footprints you say were in the apartments were from the bush guy??

Just a few ...god I would love to interrogate this man in a room.I would get some answers from him.Maybe make him kneel on glass ashtrays and deprive him of food and water...that should work...if it doesn't i''ll just bat him about the head with a cardboard tube until he talks...if he still doesn't i'll get my pals to kick the sh#t out of him and then pretend that he tried to throw himself down a flight of stairs.

Maybe i'll stick pictures of his loved ones around the room too just to add to his upset and frustration...bit of emotional black mail goes a long ways doesn't it goncy baby???
avatar
clairesy
Grand Member
Grand Member

Number of posts : 2698
Age : 32
Location : uk
Registration date : 2008-06-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Guest on Tue Aug 05, 2008 7:02 am

Very good indeed Rosie, I applaude you.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Tinkerbell43 on Tue Aug 05, 2008 7:08 am

Rosie, I guess number 87 should be, why did you ignore the email from John Lowe 2 days BEFORE you made the McCanns arguidos, warning that the DNA samples were inconclusive and yet still proceed to make The McCanns arguido's ?
avatar
Tinkerbell43
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 1473
Age : 53
Registration date : 2008-04-18

Back to top Go down

One from me

Post by dianeh on Tue Aug 05, 2008 11:24 am

Why would you think for one minute that Madeleine hadnt been sleeping in that bed? I just took a look at the photo of the bedroom, and the bed has clearly been slept in by a little person.

My daughter tends to sleep very soundly and doesnt move much, and often her bed is just like the one in the photot, with a few wrinkles and the bed turned down a bit. After all, this was a little three year old not a 20 stone man, that had been in the bed.

Beggars belief.
avatar
dianeh
Grand Member
Grand Member

Number of posts : 3465
Age : 53
Location : Outback, Australia
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Guest on Tue Aug 05, 2008 5:27 pm

GA, do you drive a MK3 Cortina or an Audi Quatro?

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by maria on Tue Aug 05, 2008 11:21 pm

Rosie

One more:

Why didn't you order the twins to be checked for sedation in spite of Kate's insistence?

(this is on the process, reported by detective/inspector Ricardo Paiva and could reinforce number 60)


Last edited by maria on Tue Aug 05, 2008 11:24 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : missing information)
avatar
maria
Grand Member
Grand Member

Number of posts : 1128
Location : Portugal
Registration date : 2008-07-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by littleminx on Wed Aug 06, 2008 1:08 am

hiya rosie.

here is another question i would like to see answerd...

IS it true that the key to the mccans apartment was a copy !! if so were is the origanal key!!
avatar
littleminx
Master
Master

Number of posts : 450
Age : 50
Location : west midlands
Registration date : 2008-06-04

Back to top Go down

Hi Minx and Maria

Post by Rosie on Wed Aug 06, 2008 4:02 am

Those questions are already covered in there. :D But if you have anything else please let me know, soon I will collate the list and tidy up and send it off *somewhere*. ;)
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by zenandpeace on Wed Aug 06, 2008 1:07 pm

Rosiepops, bravo to you for posting these questions. Many of us would like to know the answers and turn the tables on Amaral.

I have a few questions for him.

Why did you find it necessary to leak Kate McCann's diaries to the press. You knew those were her innermost thoughts and yet you did not respect her right to privacy. Why?

Did the wives of the Portuguese officers under your command influence this investigation by suggesting Kate wasn't behaving as they thought a grieving mother should?

Did you release your book before the files were made public as an attempt to deflect attention away from the fact that you did nothing to find this child?


Last edited by zenandpeace on Thu Aug 07, 2008 1:32 am; edited 2 times in total

zenandpeace
Newbie
Newbie

Number of posts : 3
Registration date : 2008-07-03

Back to top Go down

zen and pace

Post by Guest on Wed Aug 06, 2008 1:09 pm

yes true zenand peace

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

A QUESTION FOR AMARAL

Post by kateno.51 on Wed Aug 06, 2008 9:15 pm

The frontier with Spain is almost 100 miles from where Madeleine was abducted, about 1 hour 45 minutes drive. But border guards were only alerted to Madeleine's disappearance 12 hours later giving the abductors ample time to get to Spain and beyond. Why wait 12 hours before alerting the border guards?

It was 48 HOURS before police got round to searching vehicles at the border. Incredibly, weeks later the border was closed almost immediately after reports of a car being stolen. Why close the border almost immediately for a stolen car and yet a child has been reported missing and the border is not closed for 2DAYS? What is that about?

Jane Tanners sighting of a man carrying a child outside the apartment. The police said the man was 5"10. Jane Tanner said the man was about 5" 7.

Two men who were seen in an unused apartment that looked on to the tapas bar on the third of May. Were they thoroughly checked out?

What were your movements mr amaral, what phonecalls and texts did you make? Not only from the night Madeleine went missing, days or even the week before, what was your every move? Truthfully. Where is Murat in all of this? As for his lawyer. What kind of sane person would say the McCann's deserve to be cursed? The lawyer was raging that people are funding a couple who abandoned their children to swan around with bulging bank balances. Their bank balances are none of his business!

Oh and mr. amaral. Let's look at all bank statements over the last ten years and see if all "Tally" up.

kateno.51
Rookie
Rookie

Number of posts : 62
Location : lanarkshire glasgow scotland
Registration date : 2008-05-23

Back to top Go down

Hi all

Post by Rosie on Wed Aug 06, 2008 9:42 pm

OK that first post is now full so I will have to start another.

will do that later and add the questions and will try and get them both side by side, I may lock the thread for a short while, when I do this to enable me to get them together, so there is not a long gap between them. thumbsup2

Zen and Kate great questions I will include them on the next run.
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Questions!

Post by Mandz on Thu Aug 07, 2008 2:00 am

Apologies if some have been mentioned!

It was reported on TV by Martin B that it took over a week for the police to visit the only supermarket therefore why?
It was reported by Martin B on TV that the police did not do door to door knocks right away therefore why?
Did you ever consider there maybe a link between Joana and Maddie?
Why did you refuse Scotland Yard experts help?
If you felt so strongly that the parents were involved then why allow them to drive their car in for examination?
Why was the shutter not taken away and stripped down for proper analysis?
Why was the wall outside the flat not examined for footprints by the forensic team?
Why was the car park outside Maddie window not looked at for tyre prints?
What is odd about contacting Sky when your child goes missing? It’s the done thing in Britain and did you consider cultural differences?
Why did you tell the McCann’s not to speak to the Spanish journalist who claimed he knew of a french paedophile who was on his way to Portugal for his next victim?
Did Kate refuse to answer the stupid questions (in my opinion) after the alleged deal -2 year jail sentence?
Ididn'tdoit moony
avatar
Mandz
Apprentice's Assistant
Apprentice's Assistant

Number of posts : 203
Registration date : 2008-04-28

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Rosie on Fri Aug 08, 2008 3:25 am

I have come up with 86 questions I would like to ask Goncalo Amaral, if you have anymore please feel free to post them and I will add them to the running total.

Running Total 86 89 93 101 104 106 135 141 148 153 158 and still rising! (keep them coming, they are flooding in by email too) It appears that many people would like Goncalo Amaral to answer questions!

Questions to Amaral...

  1. You had a call from an English couple in deep distress, their daughter had vanished, the whole of PDL (except for Robert Murat) was out searching for her.

  2. Why did *you* assume the child had wandered off?

  3. Did you yourself and your men think to search the wardrobe and behind the sofa?

  4. Did you not consider sweeping the wardrobe and behind the sofa for vital evidence, in fact did you not consider closing down the apartment and getting it properly examined by properly trained forensics teams *IMMEDIATELY*?

  5. Why did you leave this couple to do their own searching, while you went home to bed?

  6. In view that it was *YOUR* obligation and *YOUR* job to see that a crime scene is properly secured, why did *YOU* allow so many people to contaminate it?

  7. Why did you expect distraught parents to do *your* job and secure a crime scene?

  8. Why did you not go to the scene and take control of the situation and do your job properly?

  9. Why did you not stay and order the flat to be cleared of all people that should not be there and then order that it be cordoned off *IMMEDIATELY*?

  10. Why did you go home *knowing that the crime scene was being contaminated* and go to sleep and then ask the parents why they allowed people into the apartment?

  11. Is it true that you never attended the scene yourself on the night Madeleine was abducted, but coordinated the investigation by phone? Where *exactly* did you coordinate this investigation from?

  12. If the above is true, then did you tell the investigating officers to secure the crime scene?

  13. If it is true that you never attended the scene that night of May 3rd, how were you so sure that Madeleine was not abducted? How do you know that Kate sat on Madeleine's bed traumatised unable to move?

  14. How was it possible to coordinate the search for a missing toddler over the telephone?

  15. To an ordinary person, you are told a child has gone missing, the first thing you do is to search the place. *BEHIND* the sofa in the *WARDROBE* behind the *CURTAINS*, why do you think this is odd? Why did *YOU* not stop them?

  16. Why did you not organise a search for the child IMMEDIATELY?

  17. Why did you not get a forensics team in IMMEDIATELY?

  18. Why did you not set an operations centre up in Mark Warner and order the lock down of the complex?

  19. Why did you not ask MW manager for a list of all staff and all people holidaying immediately?

  20. Why did you not order the organisation of the immediate interviewing of all MW staff and residents?

  21. Have you taken DNA samples from all residents, all holiday makers and all staff present at MW on and shortly before May 3rd?

  22. Why did you not order the Spanish borders with Portugal to be informed you had a missing child believed abducted and issue them with photographs and details?

  23. Same with the Marina just short distance away, why did you not order the lock down of this Marina?

  24. Why did you not inform authorities at the airport?

  25. Why did it take you 12 hours after Madeleine went missing to alert all border controls?

  26. Why did you allow Mark Warner cleaning staff to come in and clean apartment 5a and then ask Kate McCann why the flat had been cleaned?

  27. Why did you allow MW staff to enter this flat *a crime scene* and remove *vital evidence* such as the child's bedding?

  28. If you did not attend the crime scene and view the bed for yourself, how could you say that the bed did not look like it had been slept in? In any even the bed did look like it had been slept in by a small child and it looked like someone had turned the bedclothes back to lift her out. Why did you say that the bed was harldy touched then accuse Kate of sitting on it?

  29. Did you at anytime think that the abductor could have been putting up a pretence and searching the flat?

  30. Why did you not order an immediate circulation of this child's picture, so people knew who they were looking for?

  31. During the *POLICE* searches, and with the police present, in what locations was Maddie searched for, how and in what manner?

  32. Where were you during these searches and what were you doing?

  33. Why did you not organise an immediate 15K ring search centering around the area that Madeleine disappeared from?

  34. Why did you not order an immediate fingertip search at first light outside from where Madeleine went missing, instructing people what to look for, cigarette butts, matches, etc and tell them how to gather and secure this evidence?

  35. How many flats have been searched in the MW complex and when were they searched?

  36. When were the MW buildings searched? ie cellars, offices, backs of restaurants, empty apartments etc?

  37. How many private properties near to the MW complex have been searched?

  38. Did you organise an immediate search of all barns, gardens and cellars in the immediate vicinity?

  39. How many 3 and 4 hour long lunch breaks did you take during the 4 months you were meant to be looking for Madeleine McCann?

  40. Do you always drink alcohol while on duty?

  41. Is it a part of your investigative techniques to talk about and reveal highly sensitive information during an ongoing high profile police investigation?

  42. Is it true that finger prints were not lifted from this apartment until five days after Madeleine went missing?

  43. Is it true that the first finger prints lifted from the apartment were not taken properly and had to be re taken?

  44. Why didn't the forensics technician taking the finger prints from the shutter and the bedroom window dress appropriately in accordance with international guidelines for taking forensic evidence?

  45. Is it true that proper forensic examination of this flat did not take place until Day 100 after Madeleine went missing?

  46. When did you order a list of all paedophiles known to be in the area at this time?

  47. Have you been in touch with the German police and the Swiss police about two paedophiles known to be in Praia da Luz at the time of Madeleine McCann's disappearance?

  48. What time did the first call come in to which the GNR responded?

  49. What time did the GNR request the PJ to come to the apartment?

  50. How long after the call came in did it take you to respond to the GNR and what time did you arrive at the apartment?

  51. Did you immediately dispatch teams of your men and the GNR to do preliminary searches?

  52. Why were the bins in luz allowed to be emptied shortly after Madeleine went missing?

  53. Has the waste tip where the rubbish from Praia da Luz is taken been searched thoroughly for any signs of Madeleine, or her pyjamas or anything else missing?

  54. Did you yourself question all known witnesses that night of May 3rd?

  55. Is it true that the witness Mrs Pamela Fenn said she heard A child crying and did NOT say she heard Madeleine crying?

  56. Did you ask your men to ask for all witnesses to come forward and make a list of them before you left the apartment that night to go home to bed?

  57. How long did you sleep knowing that a small child was missing from her bed?

  58. Do you always assume that small children going missing from their beds in the evenings have gone wandering off on their own in the dark?

  59. Did you think of asking the parents to ask the twins if they saw something? (Even though they were very small and asleep and you probably would not get a coherent logical answer?)

  60. Mr McCann pointed out to you he thought it was odd that the twins remained asleep during all the commotion, did you not think of getting the twins tested and physically examined by a doctor immediately as he suggested?

  61. Did you not think to stay and help this couple who were alone in a foreign country unable to speak the language, alone panicking and petrified?

  62. Taking the above into consideration, why did you think it was odd that a relative of theirs back in England contacted Sky news, some hours after Madeleine disappeared?

  63. Are you familiar with time immediately after a child is kidnapped, which is referred to as the *Golden Hours*? If you are, why did you not attend the scene, preferring to coordinate over the phone? How long *exactly* did you spend on the phone coordinating this investigation?

  64. Do you as a serving detective, not know the European drill for a missing child believed abducted? Where circulating a photo to the media is considered of vital importance?

  65. Were you aware of the 'Child Rescue Alert System' which has been employed across Europe since 2007? which was actually in force at the time Madeleine McCann went missing?

  66. If you did know of this drill, why did you not put the 6 Bullet Point list into operation immediately?
    *Description of the child
    *Scanned photo of the child
    *Details of location and nature of the offence
    *Description of the offender(s)
    *CCTV/photo of the offender(s)


  67. Concerning you professional career, how many missing child/abduction cases have you investigated?

  68. What was the outcome of those cases?

  69. Is there any controversy over those cases?

  70. Why did you think of bringing in sniffer dogs from the UK one month AFTER Madeleine went missing?

  71. When the McCann's moved out of this apartment, who else had access to it?

  72. Was the flat cordoned off and kept locked and secured and was it guarded at all times by a police guard after the McCann's had moved out?

  73. In your opinion could anyone have had sufficient time, motive and opportunity to plant evidence in that apartment?

  74. Can this scent of death be produced in a laboratory for dog training purposes? Is this produced in any lab in Portugal? Have you checked to see if anyone had recently purchased such a product? Have you checked out all those that have access to such product?

  75. Why did you deliberately pursue this line of enquiry reagrding the sniffer dogs when you *KNEW* that it was an extremely tenuous link to forensic evidence? When you knew because you had been told by the FSS in Birmingham that the evudence was inclonclusive and could have belonged to a great many of the population?

  76. Did you ever think that there may have been evidence left by the abductor/s that could have made the dogs react in this way?

  77. Is it a possibility that such evidence could have been missed because you did not order the immediate securing of a crime scene?

  78. Is it a possibility that the evidence of cleaning you have asked Mrs McCann about, could have been the evidence of cleaning left by the MW cleaners that you allowed to enter and clean a crime scene in the first few days after Madeleine disappeared?

  79. Is it possible that the blood found in the apartment 5a was found to be that of an Eastern European Male?

  80. Is it possible that the blood indicated by the above was what the dogs reacted to?

  81. Is it possible that the apartment was then cleaned again by those allowed to rent the apartment weeks after Madeleine went missing?

  82. Have you traced, spoken to and checked out the professions and the occupants of those that rented the apartment after Madeleine went missing?

  83. Is it true that pieces of paper which could have contained vital information in this investigation were just strewn about the PJ offices?

  84. Did you have a proper scene of crime room out of which to operate?

  85. Is it possible that the scent the dogs reacted to could have been placed there by previous holidaying occupants of apartment 5a before the McCann's arrived?

  86. When the cars were lined up to be exposed to the sniffer dogs, why did you allow this procedure to take place in a public car park and not a scientifically controlled scene?

  87. When these cars were lined up to be exposed to the dogs, why did you allow the McCann's hire car to remain highly identifiable by allowing the find Madeleine bright yellow stickers all over it?

  88. Is it true that the sniffer dogs walked past all cars in the line up indicating a NEGATIVE

  89. Bearing that in mind, how do you account for saying these dogs have never given a false sign in 200 cases?

  90. When the dogs walked past this vehicle and *FAILED* to indicate a positive reaction, why did you insist that they be brought back and walked around the car until they did indicate a positive?

  91. Did you have any idea that the dogs may indicate a positive if they were repeatedly subjected to walking around this particular vehicle?

  92. Is it true that the leaked report to the press of a boot print found inside the flat and on the bumper of the McCann's hire care was that of policeman belonging to the GNR?

  93. Is it true that ALL DNA evidence that has been found both inside the flat and the hire car is mitochondrial DNA which could have belonged to Madeleine, Amelie or Kate herself?

  94. Is it true that you misinterpreted the DNA evidence from the FSS in Birmingham UK AND that from the Portuguese forensic science lab?

  95. Why did you ignore the email from John Lowe of the FSS in Birmingham, 2 days BEFORE you made the McCanns arguidos, warning that the DNA samples were inconclusive and yet you still proceeded to make The McCanns arguidos ?

  96. Is it normal in Portugal for someone you suspect in the case you are investigating to be allowed allowed to translate during key witness interviews?

  97. Do you really think it unusual that the mother of a missing child, who has brought the worlds media to help in their plight, then found her husband has been made an arguido the night before (after answering all his questions)and realising you "want" them to be guilty, rather than investigate the real perpetrator, doesn't answer all your ridiculous questions?

  98. Why did you make them arguidos and then complain Kate would not answer questions, exercising her right to remain silent under the arguid status t you yourself placed her under?

  99. If you wanted Kate to answer your questions, why didn't you make her a witness, explaining that under Portuguese law, *witnesses* are obliged by law to answer police questions?

  100. Is it true you made the McCann's arguidos "too hastily" just 8 days BEFORE the law was Due to change in Portugal?

  101. Is it true that if you had waited to make the McCann's arguidos, you would have had to produce hard and fast evidence to do so? Is it true that you made the McCann's arguidos then because you had *NO* evidence to back your suspicions?

  102. Is it true that you presided over a highly sensitive investigation where leaks from within this investigation were repeatedly used to blacken the characters of Kate and Gerry McCann?

  103. Who do you think as been leaking highly sensitive reports to the Portuguese press?

  104. Why do you think they would leak these confidential reports to the press?

  105. Is it true that you dismissed many sightings..one in particular in Morocco, on the grounds that you assume Madeleine is dead and her parents are to blame?

  106. Is it also true that a member of the hotel staff saw a man hiding in the bush near the McCanns apartment??And Were there any footprints in the ground under that bush? If there were what was done about them? Were they investigated or ignored as many other sightings and leads appeared to have been? And if this is true, why?


Last edited by Rosiepops on Sun Aug 17, 2008 2:51 am; edited 3 times in total
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

2nd Run Of Questions Beginning Number 107

Post by Rosie on Fri Aug 08, 2008 3:30 am

It appears from the response by email and PM's that there are many people that wish to ask Goncalo Amaral some questions about the handling of this investigation. The opening thread is now full, so I have started another, we commence at number 107. As usual anyone that has a question that wish answered please post it on this thread and I will add it on.

  1. 107. Do you, or anyone else that you know of have any financial assets which might suffer as a result of it becoming known that a child was abducted in the Algarve?

    108. Did you hold any of those same conflicting interests when Joana was abducted? (it is just a question not a statement)

    109. In your opinion would a family oriented resort catering largely to British visitors suffer if it became known that a British child had been abducted by a human trafficking ring operating in the Algarve?

    110. What date did your dog die and what contact did you have with the dogs cadaver?

    111. Did you or any of your men have contact with dead or drowned human bodies prior to the sniffer dogs being brought to Portugal?

    112. Is it true and are you aware of the *FACT* that two of the by-products of decomposition, putrescine and cadaverine, have been bottled and are commercially available as dog training aids. But they are also present in *ALL* decaying organic material, and in human saliva?

    113. According to rumours leaked about the McCanns from these sources "close to the PJ" the group were said to have drank 14 bottles of wine on the night of May 3? The bill from the restaurant in your files indicates ONLY 2 bottle of wine and several bottles of non-alcoholic beverages (for the entire group) -- how would you explain that discrepancy?

    114. And why was it leaked that they had drank more wine than you actually knew to be the case? If you were having dinner with a group of 9 people, would you have more than two bottles of wine on the table?

    115. On the night of May 3, 2007 How much had you had to drink after 18:00 hours?

    116. If you had chosen to drive to Praia da Luz when the call for help was made on May 3, 2007 would you have been breaking the law?

    117. Is that in fact one of the reasons you chose to coordinate from home?

    118. We are led to believe that Praia da Luz is a quiet little place with zero crime. We are also led to believe that very few children go missing in Portugal, so when you got the call that a little foreign national child had gone missing and her parents believe she had been abducted, why did you take the unusual step to co ordinate the operation from home?

    119. Were you not worried about the preservation of the crime scene and being on the spot to put in place the routine for when a child goes missing? Were you not worried about missing the *Golden Hours*?

    120. From where did Felicia Cabrita obtain all her information and is it true that her husband is your lawyer "Antonio Cabrita"?

    121. Why did it take you over a week to instruct police to visit the only supermarket near the Ocean Club?

    122. Why did the police not carry out door to door searches immediately Madeleine was reported missing believed abducted?

    123. Due to the very close proximity (about 7 miles) that Joana Cipriano went missing did you ever consider that there may be a connection between the disappearances of Joana and Madeleine?

    124. How would you have handled a connection between these two missing children if it had emerged?

    125. Why did you refuse Scotland Yard experts help?

    126. If you felt so strongly that the parents were involved then why allow them to drive their car in for examination?

    127. Considering how important the shutter was to this investigation, why was the shutter not taken away and stripped down for proper analysis?

    128. Why was the wall outside the flat not examined for footprints by the forensic team?

    129. Why was the car park outside Madeleine's window not checked for tyre prints?

    130. What is odd about contacting Sky when your child goes missing? Did you consider cultural differences? Did you try to understand that publicity and advertising that a child has disappeared, using the media is how things are handled in Britain??

    131. Why did you tell the McCann’s not to speak to the Spanish journalist who claimed he knew of a french paedophile who was on his way to Portugal for his next victim? Especially as you were informed that there was paedophile activity in the area?

    132. Did Kate refuse to answer the stupid questions after the alleged deal -2 year jail sentence? Did she stop answering questions on the say so of her Portuguese lawyer? And how given the secrecy order, did the fact that she had not answered these questions leak out from the investigation you were then heading?

    133. Is it true that you asked for the secrecy order to be implemented in this case? Is it true that the secrecy law need NOT have been evoked in this case?

    134. Did you make Mr and Mrs McCann aware of the *FACT* that the secrecy law need not be applied in the investigation and search for their missing daughter?

    135. How often did you keep Mr Mrs McCann updated on the progress of the search for their daughter?

    136. Did you ever put a Portuguese - English speaking officer with the McCann's to liaise as a family liaison officer? If not, why not?

    137. Why did you allow apartment 5a to be used by numerous other holiday makers for 2 out of the three months since Madeleine disappeared?

    138. Did you ever return alone to inspect apartment 5a during the 3 months *after* Madeleine disappeared?

    139. Why did you not release the e-fits of the possible abductor/abductors of two potentially vital witnesses?

    140. Is it true that these witnesses saw this man hanging around observing apartment 5a and he was using a white van?

    141. Have you checked the possibility that this van may have belonged to one of the known paedophiles that were *known* to have been in Praia da Luz at the time that Madeleine McCann disappeared?

    142. Why did you not issue a public appeal? Did you check the CCTV cameras of people coming in and leaving the resort?

    143. Regarding the other arguido 'Robert Murat'. Police say they completely searched the villa, but detectives spent less than a full day collecting material and then allowed the family to return, leading some to question how thorough they actually were. It takes days to complete a thorough forensic search, so how thorough was this search and did it follow international guidelines for correct forensic procedure?

    144. Have you ever had lunch with Felicia Cabrita?

    145. Have you ever had any contact whatsoever, with Journalist Nacho Abad of Spanish television programme Ana Rosa Quintana?

    146. How in your opinion did Felicia Cabrita get hold of this 'extreme' information? Where did she get copies of witness testaments, witness names, addresses and telephone numbers?

    147. May 5 - Portuguese police reveal they believe Madeleine was abducted but is still alive and in Portugal, and say they have a sketch of a suspect.
    May 25 - Detectives finally release a description of the man reported by Jane Tanner three weeks earlier following pressure from the McCann's, their legal team and the British Government.
    Why did it take the P J 20 days to release a sketch of a suspect?

    148. Is it true that you did NOT have to apply the secrecy law in this case, but it was done because you requested it? Why did you request the secrecy laws be in place for this investigation?

    149. Do you now accept that you have been comprehensively wrong about these parents?

    150. Do you have anything to say to the abductors?

    151. How would you be able to face Madeleine and what would you say to her if/when she is found?

    152. Do you have anything to say to the abductors?

    153. If this was your child and she was taken, is this the kind of investigation she would have received – answer truthfully?

    154. How long did you actually spend on the telephone, "supposedly" coordinating this search after you were first called?

    155. How long after you knew that Madeleine had disappeared and despite the fact that you had NOT attended the scene, did you decide this was a case of a child wandering off and then intstruct your men to go home and reutrn the next morning if needed?

    156. Did it not occur to you that there was a serious situation here and perhaps you had better get to the scene, take control and coordinate it properly?

    157. How humane did you think it was to leave two panicked and distraught parents who could not speak the language alone in a foreign country, while the Golden Abductions hours ticked by?

    158. If this was not your case, how would you look upon the person conducting it? (Answer TRUTHFULLY!)


Last edited by Rosiepops on Sun Aug 17, 2008 2:49 am; edited 11 times in total
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

QUESTION FOR MR.AMARAL

Post by kateno.51 on Fri Aug 08, 2008 3:48 am

From where did Felicia Cabrita obtain all her information?

kateno.51
Rookie
Rookie

Number of posts : 62
Location : lanarkshire glasgow scotland
Registration date : 2008-05-23

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by janeGT on Fri Aug 08, 2008 6:50 am

what an excellent question Kate...I ask that too. In fact, I ask who she is really...........who she knows, is related to, etc etc

curiously interesting. hope we find out the truth of this and the rumours of who she is soon. :x
avatar
janeGT
Rookie
Rookie

Number of posts : 82
Location : UK
Registration date : 2008-05-12

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Rosie on Sat Aug 09, 2008 11:57 pm

Have added your question Kate, let me know if you think of anymore, the total has now risen to 141 and it is still rising as more questions are sent to me all the time.

It would be good if we could get someone to ask Goncalo Amaral if he would be willing to do one of his famous interviews and answer all these questions?

Wonder if he would or would he just say :Nitenite: Cya, I have just remembered a previous engagement.


Last edited by Rosiepops on Sun Aug 10, 2008 1:42 am; edited 1 time in total
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by maria on Sun Aug 10, 2008 1:27 am

Rosie

Just came to my mind: did you realise that that Joana's home 'falls' within the 15km radius where searches were made?
avatar
maria
Grand Member
Grand Member

Number of posts : 1128
Location : Portugal
Registration date : 2008-07-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Rosie on Sun Aug 10, 2008 1:40 am

Hi Maria,

Yes I did, strange that isn't it? It is included in the questions where I ask if he ever gave thought that Joana and Madeleine's disappearances may be connected.

Child abduction experts say that it is highly likely that missing children going missing within this distance and time are in fact connected. I read this somewhere but cannot find where i read it.
avatar
Rosie
Admin
Admin

Number of posts : 4358
Registration date : 2008-04-27

Back to top Go down

Re: 158 Questions We Would Like To Ask Goncalo Amaral

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Page 1 of 3 1, 2, 3  Next

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum